Civil War · Sherman's March · Union Betrayal

Ebenezer Creek: The Union Army Left Them to Die

Thousands of Black men, women, and children had followed Sherman's army across Georgia, believing the Union represented freedom. On December 9, 1864, Union General Jefferson C. Davis ordered the pontoon bridge over Ebenezer Creek pulled up while they were still crossing — trapping them on the far bank as Confederate cavalry approached. Some drowned trying to swim across. Others were re-enslaved. This was not done by the Confederacy. It was done by the United States Army.

DateDecember 9, 1864
LocationEbenezer Creek, near Savannah, Georgia
PerpetratorUnion General Jefferson C. Davis
StatusLive
The argument

The standard Civil War narrative casts the Union as liberator. Ebenezer Creek is one of the clearest refutations of that story. General Davis had no military reason to strand thousands of Black refugees on the far bank of a swollen creek as Confederate cavalry approached. He found their presence an inconvenience. His decision — to pull up the bridge while they were still crossing — sent an unmistakable message: the Union Army was fighting to preserve the nation, not to protect Black people. The disaster at Ebenezer Creek did not change Union policy, but it clarified it. It compelled Secretary of War Stanton to travel to Savannah personally to interview Black leaders — producing the January 1865 meeting that led to Special Field Order No. 15: "40 acres and a mule." That promise was revoked by Andrew Johnson four months after Lincoln was killed.

Era 1
Sherman's March and the Black Refugees
1
November–December 1864 — The March

As Sherman's Army Burns Its Way Across Georgia, Thousands of Formerly Enslaved People Follow in Its Wake. They Have Nowhere Else to Go. Confederate Cavalry Follows the Column — Specifically Targeting the Refugees Who Trail Behind the Army.

When Sherman's army began its March to the Sea in November 1864, enslaved people across the Georgia countryside understood what the army represented: the physical passage of Union force through territory where slaveholders could no longer protect their "property." Thousands left the plantations and followed the army's line of march — old men and women, mothers with children, men who carried nothing but what they could hold. By the time the army reached the coast, an estimated 25,000 formerly enslaved people were traveling with it.

General William T. Sherman was not enthusiastic about this. He regarded the refugees as an operational burden — they slowed the march, consumed supplies, and required protection from Confederate cavalry that circled the column targeting stragglers. Sherman had told his corps commanders that they were not required to take responsibility for the "hangers-on." Some commanders ignored the refugees entirely. Others provided what protection they could. General Jefferson C. Davis, commanding the XIV Corps, was explicit about his view: the refugees were not his problem.

25,000Estimated Black refugees following Sherman's army by the time it reached Savannah
~5,000Refugees estimated to be following Davis's XIV Corps column specifically at Ebenezer Creek
1Pontoon bridge across Ebenezer Creek — and Davis ordered it pulled before the refugees could cross
2
December 9, 1864 — The Crossing

Davis Orders the Bridge Pulled While Refugees Are Still on the Far Bank. Confederate Wheeler's Cavalry Arrives. Hundreds Attempt to Swim the Swollen Creek. An Unknown Number Drown. The Rest Face Re-Enslavement.

At Ebenezer Creek, a pontoon bridge had been laid for the army's crossing. The refugee column had been moving across alongside the soldiers. When Davis's rear guard had crossed, he ordered the bridge pulled up — while an estimated several thousand Black refugees were still on the far bank, with Confederate cavalry under General Joseph Wheeler approaching.

Eyewitness accounts describe the scene that followed. Some refugees attempted to swim the swollen, cold creek. Some drowned. Others were captured by Wheeler's cavalry — meaning re-enslavement. The exact number killed or re-enslaved is not known; estimates range from dozens to hundreds. Union soldiers on the near bank reportedly watched and did nothing, under orders.

"The poor negroes, in their frantic efforts to cross, were drowned; the rebels came up and shot down those who were left on the bank; others were re-enslaved."

— Captain John Kerr, Union officer and eyewitness, in testimony to the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War, 1865

Davis was not court-martialed. He was not censured. Sherman declined to take any action against him, writing that Davis had made a reasonable military decision. Davis went on to command U.S. forces during the Indian Wars after the Civil War, including actions against the Modoc people in 1873.

Era 2
The Aftermath — From Ebenezer Creek to "40 Acres"
3
January 1865 — Special Field Order No. 15

The Outrage Over Ebenezer Creek Forces Secretary of War Stanton to Savannah. He Interviews Black Leaders — Producing the January 12 Meeting That Leads to "40 Acres and a Mule." Four Months Later, Andrew Johnson Cancels the Order and Returns the Land to Former Enslavers.

News of the Ebenezer Creek disaster reached Washington and produced a political crisis. Secretary of War Edwin Stanton traveled to Savannah in January 1865 — one of the highest-ranking Union officials to meet directly with Black community leaders during the war. On January 12, 1865, Stanton and Sherman met with twenty Black ministers and community leaders, led by the Reverend Garrison Frazier. Frazier's statement — that "the best way we can take care of ourselves is to have land, and till it by our own labor" — became the basis for Sherman's Special Field Order No. 15.

Field Order No. 15 set aside 400,000 acres of land along the South Carolina and Georgia Sea Islands coast for distribution to formerly enslaved families in 40-acre plots. Approximately 40,000 people were settled on this land by the summer of 1865. When Lincoln was assassinated in April and Andrew Johnson assumed the presidency, Johnson rescinded the order and directed the Army to return the land to its former white owners. The families who had settled it were dispossessed.

400,000Acres set aside by Field Order No. 15 for Black families — roughly 40 acres per family
40,000People settled on the land by summer 1865, before Johnson's revocation
Aug 1865Month Johnson began the process of returning the Sea Island lands to former enslavers
4
1864 – Present — What Ebenezer Creek Tells Us

The Civil War Was Not Fought to Free Black People. It Was Fought to Preserve the Union. The Question of What Happened to Black People After the War Was Answered Primarily by What the Federal Government Was Willing to Enforce — and Ebenezer Creek Showed the Limits of That Willingness Before the War Even Ended.

Ebenezer Creek belongs in any honest account of the Civil War because it disrupts the liberation narrative. A Union general stranded thousands of Black refugees — people who had risked their lives to follow the promise of freedom represented by the army — on the wrong side of a creek with Confederate cavalry approaching. He faced no consequences. The incident was investigated, documented, and then largely forgotten.

What Ebenezer Creek reveals is that the Union's commitment to Black freedom was always conditional, always contested, and always subordinated to other political priorities when those priorities conflicted. That pattern — federal power deployed for Black Americans when politically convenient, withdrawn when not — runs from Ebenezer Creek through Reconstruction's end in 1877, through the failure to enforce the 14th and 15th Amendments for ninety years, through the inadequate federal response to Red Summer and the NAACP's failed campaign to make lynching a federal crime, to the present.

The chain of causation

25,000 Black refugees follow Sherman's march seeking freedom
Nov–Dec 1864
→
Davis pulls bridge at Ebenezer Creek — refugees stranded, some drowned or re-enslaved
Dec 9, 1864
→
Stanton travels to Savannah — meets Black leaders — Field Order No. 15 issued
Jan 12, 1865
→
Lincoln assassinated — Johnson takes office
Apr 1865
→
Johnson revokes Field Order No. 15 — land returned to former slaveholders
Aug 1865
→
The racial wealth gap — Black families denied the land base that built white generational wealth
1865–Present

The Union was not fighting to free Black people. Ebenezer Creek proved it.

Davis was never punished. The bridge was pulled. The refugees were abandoned. And when the war ended, the land promised in Field Order No. 15 — the one material acknowledgment that formerly enslaved people were owed something — was taken back. Ebenezer Creek is a test case for what the United States was actually willing to do when the costs of Black freedom became inconvenient.

Explore all threads