Chain · Era 7 · Civil Rights
Civil Rights & Beyond · 1967–Present

Black Political Power:
Elected Into a System Built to Constrain Them

In 1967, Carl Stokes became the first Black mayor of a major American city — Cleveland, Ohio. Maynard Jackson was elected in Atlanta in 1973. Coleman Young in Detroit in 1973. Tom Bradley in Los Angeles in 1973. Harold Washington in Chicago in 1983. David Dinkins in New York in 1989. Barack Obama in the White House in 2009. Each election was historic. Each Black leader faced the same problem: they inherited cities and institutions shaped by decades of racist policy — depleted tax bases, redlined neighborhoods, underfunded schools, hostile bureaucracies — and were held accountable for problems they did not create, with tools they were not given to solve them.

First major Black mayor
Carl Stokes, Cleveland, 1967
Atlanta to Chicago
Maynard Jackson 1973, Harold Washington 1983
Structural constraint
Black mayors inherit the consequences of racist policy
Black Mayors
The Central Argument

The election of Black political leaders to positions of formal power has repeatedly collided with a structural reality: political power without economic power cannot reverse the accumulated effects of deliberate economic exclusion. Black mayors who tried to expand city contracts to Black businesses (Maynard Jackson) faced lawsuits. Those who tried to reform police departments (Harold Washington) faced active obstruction from white aldermen. Those who inherited industrial collapse (Coleman Young in Detroit) were blamed for the collapse. The lesson is not that Black political leadership failed — it is that formal political power is insufficient without control of the economic and institutional structures beneath it.

The Mayors · 1967–Present
01
1973–1989

Maynard Jackson, Harold Washington, and the Limits of the Office

Atlanta · Chicago

Maynard Jackson's first term in Atlanta (1973–78) was defined by his insistence that Black businesses receive their fair share of city contracts — specifically the construction contracts for the new Hartsfield International Airport. White business interests sued. The city council resisted. Jackson held firm: no contracts without minority participation. By the time the airport opened, Atlanta had the most advanced minority business enterprise program in the country. Black business formation in Atlanta accelerated. The model was replicated in cities nationwide. Jackson was accused of reverse discrimination. He was using the same contracting power that had been used exclusively for white businesses for decades.

Harold Washington was elected mayor of Chicago in 1983 against the opposition of the white Democratic machine. His four years were defined by "Council Wars" — white aldermen organized by Ald. Ed Vrdolyak blocked virtually every Washington initiative in the city council for his first two years. Washington was not obstructed because he was ineffective. He was obstructed because he was effective, and effective Black political leadership in Chicago threatened the machine that had controlled city resources for generations. He won a second term in 1987 and died of a heart attack seven months later. The machine promptly reasserted control.

02
2009–2017

Obama and the Racial Rorschach Test

Washington D.C.

Barack Obama's election as the 44th President was described as proof that America had transcended race — a 'post-racial' moment that conservatives and some liberals used to argue that structural racism was no longer operative. Obama's presidency proceeded to demonstrate the opposite: he faced obstruction that historians and political scientists have documented was qualitatively different from that faced by white presidents; the 'birther' movement questioned the legitimacy of his citizenship on racial grounds; congressional Republicans stated explicitly that their primary goal was to ensure his failure; and his measured public response to racial violence (Trayvon Martin: "If I had a son, he'd look like Trayvon") produced national controversy that similar statements from white presidents never would have.

Obama's presidency produced the lowest Black unemployment in recorded history before 2019 and the Affordable Care Act, which reduced the uninsured rate among Black Americans by 10 percentage points. It also produced the election of Donald Trump, partly on a backlash to Black political power at its most visible. The election of a Black president did not signal the end of racism. It catalyzed it.

The Longer Chain

Formal political power has not been enough. It has never been enough alone.

The election of Black leaders has consistently produced backlash — legal, institutional, and violent — from Reconstruction through Obama. Formal political representation is necessary but insufficient without economic power and structural change.

Next in the chain
Fannie Lou Hamer: Sick and Tired of Being Sick and Tired
Continue →